
The Red Marker
This story is more open ended, with multiple possible answers! Make sure to have a clear argument or reason.
π Read the Story
The teacher has a red marker.
After class, the marker is gone.
Now, the marker is on the floor.
Three students are in the classroom: Emma, Ryan, and Lily.
π§© Look at the Clues
- Emma is standing near the teacherβs desk.
- Ryan says, βI did not touch the marker.β
- Lily has a notebook with red marks inside.
Question:
πWhat happened?
πI think __________ moved the marker because __________________________.
Bonus:
π
Can you think of a different idea?
Maybe ______________ because ______________.
Scroll down for the answer!

Answer:
The criminal could be anyone!
It could be Emma- she is suspiciously close to the teacher’s desk and may have touched the marker. However, she isn’t holding it at the moment.
It could be Lily because she has marker in her book. It may or may not be the teacher’s marker!
Ryan denies that he touched it, but doesn’t everyone when they are going to get in trouble? Maybe if we check his desk…
Again, there is no correct answer here!
…Did you solve the mystery? π

Link to Mystery #1:













